Turner Broadcasting System, Inc. and Subsidiaries - Page 16

                                       - 16 -                                         
          integrated, mutually dependent steps in an overall plan.  We                
          agree.  Indeed, petitioners do not characterize it differently.             
               Respondent, however, seeks to have the transactions                    
          recharacterized for tax purposes using either the step                      
          transaction or the substance-over-form doctrine.  Respondent                
          urges us to reject the form adopted by the parties.  That form              
          reflects events that actually happened, in favor of what                    
          respondent characterizes as the substance of the transaction.               
          Respondent summarizes his position as follows:                              

               The substance of this transaction should be determined                 
               by applying the terms of the [f]inal Merger Agreement                  
               and the Purchase and Sale Agreement in tandem, since                   
               the agreements were completely interdependent, and the                 
               steps of the transaction occurred simultaneously.                      
               Viewing this transaction as a whole, TBS should be                     
               treated as making a capital contribution to MGM                        
               equivalent to the value of UA.  * * *  Further, in a                   
               transaction which is in substance a bootstrap                          
               acquisition, the portion of Tracinda's MGM stock equal                 
               in value to the UA stock was redeemed by MGM in                        
               exchange for the UA stock.  * * *                                      

               In respondent's recharacterization of the "substance of the            
          transaction", MGM is deemed to have distributed its UA stock to             
          Tracinda and the Subscribing Public in exchange for a portion of            
          the shareholders' MGM stock.  If we were to agree with                      
          respondent's recharacterization as a redemption, section 311(a)             
          would provide that no loss would be recognized on MGM's                     
          distribution of UA shares in redemption of its own shares.                  







Page:  Previous  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011