Alva H. Beachy - Page 3




                                                - 3 -3                                                 

            religious order, sect, or division thereof, nor was he a                                   
            Christian Science practitioner.  From approximately 1958 to 1973,                          
            petitioner had been a member of the Amish church.  In either 1972                          
            or 1973, petitioner and several other members of the Amish church                          
            were excommunicated because of differences over certain Biblical                           
            teachings and doctrines.  Petitioner has never been readmitted                             
            into the Amish church.                                                                     
                  In the notice of deficiency, respondent determined that                              
            petitioner's net earnings from his three self-employment                                   
            activities during 1994 were subject to self-employment tax.                                
                  Petitioner's sole basis for his position is stated in his                            
            trial memorandum as follows:                                                               

                  it is my sincere honest faith, and belief, that insurance                            
                  and security programs do work contrary to the teachings of                           
                  Jesus Christ.  Jesus taught that we are not to take thought                          
                  for our life as to what we should eat or wear, but that we                           
                  rather sell what we have and give alms. * * * I do                                   
                  understand Social Security to be designed and programed much                         
                  the same as insurance, and will provide for me in the                                
                  future, when perhaps I do have a need.                                               

            On that basis, petitioner objects to the payment of taxes on                               
            self-employment.                                                                           
                  Section 1401(a) imposes a tax on the self-employment income                          
            of every individual for old age, survivors, and disability                                 
            insurance.  Section 1401(b) imposes a tax on the self-employment                           
            income of every individual for hospital insurance.  In general,                            






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011