Estate of Lloyd P. Cavett - Page 18




                                       - 18 -                                         
          compensation shall be paid to * * * [Bell], for such care,                  
          attention and services as she shall be able to render to my said            
          daughter” (the compensation provision).  Decedent’s daughter                
          predeceased him, so the compensation provision in question never            
          came into effect.  We attach very little weight to the                      
          compensation provision.  Decedent’s daughter was not Bell’s                 
          daughter.  Bell may very well have felt affection for her.                  
          Nevertheless, Bell was not a wealthy woman.  Decedent was                   
          wealthy, and his providing for compensation to be paid to Bell to           
          encourage her to look after his daughter is natural.  It tells us           
          very little about decedent’s view of his relationship with Bell             
          so long as he lived.                                                        
               D.  The Ledgers                                                        
               Apparently, the ledgers record all of the Bell payments.               
          Several of the Bell payment entries are annotated "Sal".                    
          Petitioners contend that the term "Sal" is an abbreviation for              
          the word "salary".  Petitioners argue that the monthly pattern of           
          these transfers and the identification of some of the transfers             
          as "Sal" shows that the checks were payment for services.                   
               While petitioners may have exposed an ambiguity in some of             
          the Bell payments, no dispositive evidence was presented that               
          proves the checks were not gifts.  We have found that Bell and              
          decedent had a close, personal, and loving relationship,                    
          resembling a marriage.  We are unpersuaded by any of the                    






Page:  Previous  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011