Estate of Fred O. Godley, Deceased, Fred D. Godley, Administrator CTA - Page 32




                                        - 32 -                                          
          Monroe                                                                        
               Dvorak’s Report                                                          
                    Year 1           Year 2    Year 3    Year 4    Year 5               
          Net operating                                                                 
          income1        $176,350 $176,350 $176,350   $176,350 $176,350                 
          Cash-flow      176,350  176,350  176,350 21,617,165                           
          Present value3  154,693  135,696  119,031   957,491                           
          Sum of present values:  $1,366,910                                            
          Estimated value:  $1,370,000                                                  
                    1 In contrast to his computations for Charlotte, Dvorak             
               did not inflate the net operating income figures for Monroe              
               by 1.5 percent from year to year, nor did he adjust the                  
               starting net operating income figure for inflation to state              
               it in 1989 dollars.  Dvorak gives no reason for failing to               
               make these adjustments, and for consistency we make them in              
               the table that follows.                                                  
                    2 This figure equals the reversionary value of                      
               $1,440,815 plus the net operating income from year 4 of                  
               $176,350.  The reversionary value equals the net operating               
               income from year 5, $176,350, divided by Dvorak’s terminal               
               capitalization rate of 11.75 percent, minus costs of sale of             
               $60,034.                                                                 
                    3 Dvorak discounted to present value using a 14-percent             
               discount rate.                                                           
               Court’s Adjustments                                                      
                    Year 1           Year 2    Year 3    Year 4    Year 5               
          Net operating                                                                 
          income1        $195,386 $198,317 $201,292   $204,311 $207,376                 
          Cash-flow      195,386  198,317  201,292 21,987,619                           
          Present value3  172,909  155,311  139,505  1,219,044                          
          Sum of present values:  $1,686,769                                            
          Estimated value:  $1,690,000                                                  
                    1 These figures include an adjustment to the vacancy                
               rate that we have concluded is appropriate, from 3 percent               
               down to 1 percent.  This caused an increase of $5,019 (2                 
               percent of the rental income figure of $250,080) each year               
               in 1985 dollars.  The figures in the table are inflated to               
               1989 dollars using Dvorak’s inflation rate of 1.5 percent                
               per year and inflated at the same rate year by year.                     




Page:  Previous  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011