Chung Ui Kim and Ok Hui Kim - Page 9




                                         - 9 -                                          
          they had engaged in an elaborate scheme to transfer the funds                 
          without the knowledge of the Korean and U.S. customs and tax                  
          authorities.5  Bok Kim testified that she repeatedly delivered                
          small amounts of Korean currency to Sung Bae Kim, an airline                  
          employee whom she identified as Ok Kim’s younger brother.6                    
          According to Bok Kim, the airline employee would arrange for the              
          conversion of the won to U.S. currency and for Korean tourists,               
          unknown to either Bok Kim or petitioners, to deliver the funds to             
          petitioner Chung Kim at his store.7  Bok Kim could not recall the             
          precise amounts of money she transferred on each occasion but                 
          believed the amounts to be in the range of 5 to 7 million Korean              
          won (approximately 5,000 to 9,000 U.S. dollars).8                             
               We find that Bok Kim’s testimony lacks credibility, is                   
          inconsistent with the record in this case, and does not credibly              
          establish a nontaxable source for the unexplained deposits.                   
          Under the circumstances, we are not required to, and we do not,               


               5Chung Kim testified that he did not request a bank wire                 
          transfer because it is “illegal” to take out more than $10,000                
          from Korea.  He also stated that he wanted to avoid any “tax                  
          consequences” such a transfer would entail for either him or his              
          niece.                                                                        
               6Chung Kim identified Sung Bae Kim as his wife’s nephew, not             
          her brother.  Sung Bae Kim did not testify.                                   
               7Neither Bok Kim nor petitioner identified the names of any              
          of the individuals who allegedly delivered the funds to Mr. Kim.              
               8Despite allegedly transferring nearly all of her father’s               
          substantial estate with no true expectation of repayment, Bok Kim             
          also testified that she had come to Court to help her uncle                   
          “because it’s not like I had done much for him before.”                       




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011