Vernon Miller - Page 12




                                               - 12 -                                                  
            to the Miller loan.13                                                                      
                  Based on our examination of the entire record in this case,                          
            we find that petitioner has failed to establish that he is                                 
            entitled to any deduction under section 166 with respect to the                            
            Miller loan.                                                                               
                  We address now whether petitioner is entitled to a deduction                         
            under any other provision of the Code with respect to the Miller                           


                  13Assuming arguendo that we had found that petitioner estab-                         
            lished that the Miller loan was a business debt for purposes of                            
            sec. 166 and that the $2,641 of unrecovered principal of that                              
            loan became worthless during 1993, we nonetheless find on the                              
            instant record that petitioner has failed to show that the amount                          
            of the deduction under sec. 166(a) with respect to that loan, as                           
            determined under sec. 166(b), includes $109,482 of legal expendi-                          
            tures that he claims he incurred in pursuing the Miller loan                               
            litigation.  As we understand it, petitioner bases his contention                          
            that such alleged expenditures are to be included as part of the                           
            adjusted basis of the Miller loan as determined under sec. 166(b)                          
            because the note evidencing that loan contained the following                              
            provision:  “Should suit be commenced to collect this note or any                          
            portion thereof, such sum as the Court may deem reasonable shall                           
            be added hereto as attorney’s fees.”  We note first that peti-                             
            tioner has failed to establish on the record in this case that he                          
            paid $109,482 of legal expenses as of the end of 1993.  The                                
            record establishes that as of the end of that year petitioner had                          
            incurred only $90,999 of legal expenses, of which only $46,593                             
            had been paid.  Moreover, on the record in this case, we find no                           
            evidence that any court directed in the year at issue or in any                            
            year prior to or after that year that any amount, let alone a                              
            reasonable amount, be added to the principal of the Miller loan                            
            as attorney’s fees.  Assuming arguendo that we had found that                              
            petitioner established that the Miller loan was a business debt                            
            for purposes of sec. 166 and that the $2,641 of unrecovered                                
            principal of that loan became worthless during 1993, on the                                
            record before us, we find that petitioner has failed to persuade                           
            us that $109,482 of legal expenditures are includible under sec.                           
            166(b) in determining the amount of deduction allowable for a                              
            business bad debt under sec. 166(a).                                                       




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011