Jacob and Chana Pinson, et al. - Page 6




                                        - 6 -                                         
          weighing of the relative potential for prejudice to petitioners             
          and to respondent convinces us that justice will be better served           
          by allowing leave to amend.                                                 
               First, before addressing more substantive matters, we make a           
          practical observation.  Petitioners allege that the estimated               
          cost to each of the four moving parties, if deductions for the              
          $1,292,699 paid apiece in Israeli income taxes are denied, will             
          be more than $1 million in additional U.S. tax, interest, and               
          penalties.  (The $1,292,699 figure derives from adding the                  
          $296,554, $704,450, and $291,695 in taxes paid by each moving               
          party in 1991, 1992, and 1994, respectively.)  The economic                 
          impact of our decision thus will not be insignificant.                      
               We now turn to the substance underlying the relief claimed             
          and its relationship to the record developed in this case.  As              
          explained in our earlier opinion, payment of taxes to a foreign             
          government may give rise to either a deduction or a credit.  See            
          secs. 164, 901.  Section 164(a)(3) provides that a deduction is             
          allowed for foreign income taxes.  In lieu of this deduction,               
          section 901(a) and (b)(1) permits a taxpayer to elect a credit              
          for foreign income taxes.                                                   
               Subject to limited exceptions not relevant here, the                   
          deduction and credit provisions operate on a mutually exclusive             
          basis with respect to a particular tax year.  See sec.                      
          275(a)(4)(A).  A taxpayer is precluded from deducting foreign               






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011