Harland and Shirley Stonecipher - Page 14




                                        -14-                                          
          through 1992 and possibly through 1993) of all their female                 
          calves.1  These circumstances speak loudly to the nonprofit                 
          nature of petitioners’ cattle ranch activity, particularly where            
          the buildup of the cattle herd and the profit were to be based on           
          the successful breeding of the cows.                                        
               Petitioners claim that the for-profit nature of the cattle             
          ranch is indicated by, among other things, the no-frills nature             
          of the property, the lack of recreational use of the property,              
          and the alleged long-range plan or purpose to use income from the           
          ranch to support petitioners in their retirement.  With regard              
          specifically to the alleged long-range plan, petitioners offered            
          into evidence a calendar for 1983 on which were entered a few               
          brief words as follows:                                                     

                              Retire age 60 — 1998                                    
                              2500 acres paid                                         
                              500 mama cows paid                                      

               We do not believe that this brief calendar entry adequately            
          corroborates the existence of a long-range business or profit               
          plan for the ranch.  Rather, we regard the calendar entry as                
          reflecting, at most, a general goal or desire.  The credible                



               1 The parties have stipulated that “During the years 1982              
          through 1993, petitioners sold the cattle raised each year.”                
          Petitioner testified, on the other hand, that he temporarily                
          stopped selling heifers after a 1992 price drop.  To the extent             
          there is a discrepancy, we do not view it as material to our                
          analysis or to the result reached herein.                                   





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011