Donald J. Janda - Page 10



                                       - 10 -                                         
          book Quantifying Marketability Discounts (1997), to arrive at a             
          valuation of $108,436 for each of petitioners’ separate                     
          transfers.  According to Mr. Mercer, an appraiser using the QMDM            
          model is able to quantify the impact of the factors that                    
          influence marketability discounts in real-life settings.  See id.           
          at 209.                                                                     
               As described by Mr. Mercer, an appraiser first values the              
          shareholder’s investment at the entity level, resulting in a                
          valuation of the investment as if it were marketable.  See id. at           
          171-184.  In his book, Mr. Mercer generally arrives at the entity           
          level valuation using the capitalization of earnings method,                
          which considers current earnings per share, an anticipated                  
          earnings growth, and an appropriate discount rate accounting for            
          the inherent risk with regard to investing in a particular                  
          company.  See id.  The net amount of the discount rate less the             
          anticipated earnings growth is referred to as the capitalization            
          rate, which is multiplied against the earnings per share.  See              
          id.  After that computation is made, the appraiser has generated            
          the marketable value of 1 share in the investment.  See id.  Mr.            
          Mercer then suggests that the appraiser adjust the value of the             
          stock upward for a control premium or downward for a minority               
          interest.  See id.                                                          
               After the value of the marketable investment at the entity             
          level is computed, the appraiser applies the QMDM model to                  
          account for the fact that the growth in the value of the                    






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011