Laborers' International Union of North America - Page 9




                                        - 9 -                                         
               petitioner remain associate member dues for access to                  
               health insurance. * * *  Respondent contends that the                  
               character of the income does not change when the income                
               is apportioned between petitioner, Mail Handlers, and                  
               Mail Handlers’ Local Unions.                                           
          We again find respondent’s argument and factual analysis flawed.            
          We have found, and respondent cites, no authority for the novel             
          proposition that the character of the income does not change                
          “when the income is apportioned between petitioner, Mail                    
          Handlers, and Mail Handlers’ Local Unions.”  Nor do we find that            
          petitioner, Mail Handlers, and Mail Handlers’ Local Unions were             
          in a joint enterprise that “apportioned” dues received by Mail              
          Handlers from Mail Handlers’ associate members.  The proper                 
          characterization of the income of parties not before the Court              
          is, in the instant case, not relevant to the proper                         
          characterization of petitioner’s receipts of per capita taxes.              
               We conclude that the receipt of per capita taxes calculated            
          with reference to the number of associate members of Mail                   
          Handlers is not UBTI to petitioner.  Accordingly, for the reasons           
          set out above,                                                              
                                                  Decision will be entered            
                                             for petitioner.                          














Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  

Last modified: May 25, 2011