- 3 - determinations, we describe relevant parts of the procedural histories of the instant cases. Procedural Histories A. The Trust On May 12, 1999, Andy Hromiko, in his capacity as trustee, filed a petition for the trust. In the petition, the trustee alleged that the trust was a business trust entitled to the business deductions claimed on the filed tax returns.1 The trustee requested that the matter be transferred to the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) Appeals Office on the ground that the notice of deficiency was incomplete and erroneous, that the trust had been denied its due process under law, and that it had a substantial claim against the IRS under “the Taxpayer Bill of Rights”. Further, the trustee listed 10 affirmative defenses on behalf of the trust: 1. Res judicata 2. Estoppel 3. Waiver 4. Duress 5. Fraud 6. Statute of limitations 7. Invalid notice of deficiency not complying with the tax code provisions 8. The “clean hands” doctrine (unclean hands of respondent) 9. Illegality 10. Violation of Taxpayer Bill of Rights 1 With regard to petitioner’s actions as a fiduciary of the trust, we refer to him as the trustee in this opinion.Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Next
Last modified: May 25, 2011