Larry M. Petty and Jean L. Petty - Page 10




                                       - 10 -                                         
          petitioners rely to establish their entitlement to deduct for               
          1993 the expenses remaining at issue that they claimed in Sched-            
          ule C for “Repairs and maintenance” shows that they paid amounts            
          during 1993 totaling $5,020.68.  However, petitioners claimed a             
          deduction in Schedule C for “Repairs and maintenance” of only               
          $3,748, of which, as noted above, respondent conceded $865 at               
          trial, leaving only $2,883 which remains at issue.  Furthermore,            
          the documentary evidence on which petitioners rely to support               
          their entitlement to deduct for 1993 the $2,883 of claimed                  
          Schedule C expenses for “Repairs and maintenance” that remain at            
          issue included a number of checks which do not even involve or              
          relate to repair and/or maintenance expenses.7  On the instant              
          record, we find that petitioners have failed to establish that              
          the entire amount of $5,020.68 that the record establishes they             
          paid during 1993 relates to “Repairs and maintenance”.  We                  
          further find on the record before us that petitioners have failed           
          to prove that such paid amounts are ordinary and necessary                  
          expenses paid during 1993 in carrying on Mr. Petty’s truck                  


               7For example, three of the checks petitioners introduced               
          into evidence to substantiate their claimed Schedule C expenses             
          for “Repairs and maintenance” represent amounts paid for car                
          titles and registrations; two of such checks represent amounts              
          paid for ads; and four of such checks represent amounts paid for            
          items not established by the record.  In this connection, Mr.               
          Petty indicated at trial that a number of the checks introduced             
          by petitioners with respect to the deductions claimed in Schedule           
          C for “Repairs and maintenance” represented “a bunch of checks as           
          an afterthought, that I put in here.”                                       





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011