Will L. and Rachel A. Thomas - Page 5




                                        - 5 -                                         

          benefits in an amount equal to a prescribed formula therein                 
          provided.  Petitioners have not challenged the computation by               
          respondent under this formula.                                              
               The Court rejects petitioners' contention that disability              
          Social Security benefits constitute accident or health insurance            
          under section 104(a)(3).  The repeal by Congress of former                  
          section 105(d), which specifically provided for the exclusion               
          from income of certain disability benefits and the enactment of             
          section 86, with the section 86(d)(1)(A) provision that the term            
          "Social Security benefits" includes benefits received under title           
          II of the Social Security Act (which includes disability Social             
          Security benefits), indicates quite clearly to the Court that               
          Congress did not intend that disability Social Security benefits            
          could be construed as an accident or health plan under section              
          104(a)(3), or that disability Social Security benefits are                  
          otherwise excludable from gross income.  The Court, therefore,              
          rejects petitioners' contention on this issue.                              
               Petitioners' final argument is leveled at the                          
          constitutionality of section 86.  Petitioners argue that, if                
          employees of a State or territory of the United States, including           
          the District of Columbia, are entitled to exclude from income               
          sickness or disability benefits under accident and health plans             









Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011