Best Auto Sales, Inc. - Page 9




                                        - 9 -                                         
               The fact that some payments on debts become delinquent,                
          standing alone, does not establish the worthlessness or                     
          uncollectibility of the debts or of any portion thereof.                    
          Milenbach v. Commissioner, 106 T.C. 184, 204-205 (1996).                    
               A taxpayer’s business judgment concerning whether debts in a           
          particular year are partially worthless, if clearly supported by            
          facts, may be sufficient to prove the partial worthlessness of              
          the debts for a particular year.  Portland Manufacturing Co. v.             
          Commissioner, supra at 73.                                                  
               Petitioners argue that the alleged “sound business judgment”           
          of petitioners has been established by the loan delinquencies,              
          the automobile repossessions, and the inherent nature of the                
          loans made to high credit risk customers.  We disagree.                     
               We perceive little “sound business judgment” in petitioners’           
          method of charging off the loans in issue.  Rather, petitioners’            
          method was arbitrary and unrelated to the exercise of any                   
          meaningful discretion with respect to particular loans.                     
          Essentially, because petitioners’ automobile loans were made to             
          high risk customers, petitioners would have us treat all of their           
          automobile loans to customers whose cars were repossessed as                
          inherently worthless from the day the loans originated.  We                 
          reject that treatment.  The facts of loan delinquency and                   
          automobile repossession in a year, combined with high risk                  
          debtors, do not automatically establish the full or partial                 






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011