Christie E. Cuddeback and Lucille M. Cuddeback Memorial Fund - Page 32




                                       - 32 -                                         
             June 28, 2000, which states that "Cuddeback funds have been              
             used to assist veterans whose benefits for medical daycare               
             have been exhausted"; they have been used as a ready source              
             of funds to assist families "until other funding sources                 
             could be obtained"; and they have been used "as a                        
             supplement to other funding sources when those funds were                
             not adequate."  Furthermore, the financial information for               
             FY 2000 shows a budget for "charity care" of ($179,478) and              
             "Actual (Projected)" charity care of ($54,347).  According               
             to Keswick's letter, those amounts include "the funding                  
             received from the Cuddeback trust", but the letter does not              
             further explain what those figures are.  The existence of                
             other funding sources suggests that Keswick's grant program              
             may not depend on petitioner's contributions, and it casts               
             doubt on petitioner's assertion that "50% of the total                   
             grants were supplied by Petitioner's distribution".                      
                  As mentioned above, petitioner's argument that Keswick              
             will be attentive to its operations is premised on the                   
             assertion that it provides 50 percent of the funds for                   
             all "grants".  We do not believe that that assertion is                  
             established by the administrative record.  First, there is               
             no showing in the administrative record that 50 percent of               
             Keswick's grants were made with funds from petitioner for                
             1996, 1997, 1998, or 2000.  Second, even for 1999, we do                 
             not agree that the administrative record shows that 50                   
             percent of all grants given by Keswick were made with                    





Page:  Previous  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011