Michael E. Nestor - Page 17




                                       - 17 -                                         
               HALPERN, J., concurring:  I agree with the majority that, if           
          in determining to proceed with collection, respondent erred in              
          informing petitioner that all applicable laws and administrative            
          procedures had been met, such error was harmless error.  I write            
          separately to express my views as to why the majority is correct.           
          I.  Introduction                                                            
               Petitioner requested and received a so-called collection due           
          process hearing.  At that hearing, the Appeals officer was                  
          required to obtain verification that the requirements of any                
          applicable law or administrative procedure had been met.  Sec.              
          6330(c)(1).  Following the hearing, the Appeals officer informed            
          petitioner that all applicable laws and administrative procedures           
          had been met and that collection from petitioner of his tax                 
          liability for 1990 through 1997 would proceed.  Petitioner                  
          contends that he was entitled to receive assessment records under           
          section 6203.1  The majority finds:                                         
                    The Appeals officer did not give petitioner a copy                
               of the record of assessment at or before the hearing as                

               1  Sec. 6203 provides:                                                 
               SEC. 6203.  METHOD OF ASSESSMENT.                                      
                    The assessment shall be made by recording the                     
               liability of the taxpayer in the office of the                         
               Secretary in accordance with rules or regulations                      
               prescribed by the Secretary.  Upon request of the                      
               taxpayer, the Secretary shall furnish the taxpayer a                   
               copy of the record of the assessment.  [Emphasis                       
               added.]                                                                






Page:  Previous  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011