- 9 -
identifies a “Carol Ruthenberg” as “creator” and Robert Hogue as
trustee. Significantly, Bella Vista made no attempt to explain
the patent discrepancies in the two purported trust
documents-–particularly the change in identity of the trust
“creator” and the change in identity of the trustees. We note
further that although the 1994 version of the trust instrument
required a minimum of two trustees, the 1997 version required
only one trustee.
In the absence of any persuasive basis for concluding that
Robert Hogue was duly appointed as the trustee of Bella Vista, we
shall dismiss this case for lack of jurisdiction consistent with
respondent’s motion, as supplemented.5
5 Robert Hogue has filed numerous petitions with the Court
on behalf of various so-called trusts. As is the case here,
those petitions were dismissed on the ground they were not filed
by a proper party. See Remedios Chiropractic Clinic Trust,
Robert Hogue, Legal Tr., docket No. 11070-01; JREP Trust, Robert
Hogue, Tr. v. Commissioner, docket No. 9795-01L; PERJ Trust,
Robert Hogue, Tr. v. Commissioner, docket No. 9794-01L; R&R
Trust, Robert Hogue, Tr. v. Commissioner, docket No. 7379-01S;
Family Chiropractic Trust, Robert Hogue, Tr. v. Commissioner,
docket No. 7378-01; PERJ Trust, Robert Hogue, Tr. v.
Commissioner, docket No. 6727-01; JREP Trust, Robert Hogue, Tr.
v. Commissioner, docket No. 6726-01; MARFRAN Trust, Robert Hogue,
Legal Tr. v. Commissioner, docket No. 12427-00S; Remedios
Chiropractic Clinic Trust, Robert Hogue, Legal Tr. v.
Commissioner, docket No. 12426-00; BLR-SLR Trust, Robert Hogue,
Legal Tr. v. Commissioner, docket No. 12425-00S; Rancho
Residential Facility Trust, Robert Hogue, Tr. v. Commissioner,
docket No. 9120-00; Residential Mgmt. Servs. Trust, Robert Hogue,
Tr. v. Commissioner, docket No. 9119-00; Home Health Servs.
Trust, Robert Hogue, Tr. v. Commissioner, docket No. 9118-00;
Sunshine Trust, Robert Hogue, Tr. v. Commissioner, docket No.
9117-00; Residential Mgmt. Servs. Trust, Robert Hogue, Tr. v.
(continued...)
Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Next
Last modified: May 25, 2011