Jerry D. Criner - Page 26

                                       - 26 -                                         
          Claremore property, although he disputes that he is the sole                
          owner as respondent contends.  Because of petitioner’s                      
          concession, the hearing officer did not have to review Oklahoma             
          State law to decide whether petitioner owns the requisite                   
          property interest to which the Federal tax lien in this case                
          attaches.                                                                   
               Second, a nominee NFTL is a collection device, and a                   
          determination by respondent to use a nominee NFTL is governed by            
          Federal law, not by Oklahoma State law.  See G.M. Leasing Corp.             
          v. United States, 429 U.S. at 350-351.  Only the determination of           
          whether a taxpayer owns an interest in, or holds rights to,                 
          property is governed by State law.  Drye v. United States, supra            
          at 478; Aquilino v. United States, supra.                                   
               Third, even if the hearing officer was required to consider            
          Oklahoma State law, petitioner has failed to show that he was               
          prejudiced by any failure on the part of the hearing officer to             
          do so.  Although the transcript of the hearing reflects that the            
          hearing officer did not research Oklahoma State law, the hearing            
          officer referred to the substance of intestacy laws of Oklahoma             
          in his discussions regarding the interest in the Claremore                  
          property that petitioner admits he inherited by reason of his               
          mother’s death in 1989.                                                     
               Fourth, Oklahoma State law recognizes the principle of                 
          equitable or beneficial ownership on which the nominee lien is              






Page:  Previous  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011