Estate of Helen A. Deputy, Deceased, William J. Deputy, Co-Executor - Page 20

                                       - 20 -                                         
          Burns derived his 5.2-percent Company/industry reduction directly           
          from a data base published by Ibbotson Associates, which suggests           
          a 5.2-percent reduction for companies in the “Ship and boat                 
          building and repairing” category.  This obviously translates into           
          a premium for that industry’s category.                                     
               Mr. Dorman, on the other hand, listed six general categories           
          and the fact that Godfrey was a small company to increase the               
          risk factors and arrive at his 3-percent adjustment in the                  
          Company/industry category.  That, of course, translates into a              
          discount for the industry category.  Here again, Mr. Dorman’s               
          explanation for his adjustment is without specifics.                        
               The estate argues that the 5.2-percent Company/industry                
          reduction that Mr. Burns obtained from the Ibbotson Associates              
          data base was inappropriate because the data, to some extent,               
          were derived from years after 1997.  Mr. Burns explained that               
          such information was not available before 2001 and the data base            
          included the years 1996 through 2001.  In defending his use of              
          that data base, Mr. Burns explained that industry risk tends to             
          trend and does not generally have spikes.  In addition, Mr. Burns           
          compared some “betas” of comparable publicly traded companies and           
          found that they had a composite 5-percent industry                          
          risk premium, which supports the 5.2-percent premium Mr. Burns              
          used.                                                                       







Page:  Previous  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011