Michael J. Downing and Sandra M. Downing - Page 49

                                       - 49 -                                         
               (b)  Petitioners do not explain the differences between                
          their contended-for amounts in their opening and answering                  
          briefs.                                                                     
               (c)  Sandra testified that her mother typically bought                 
          savings bonds for Rachel and Sean, and that her mother kept the             
          bonds until well after the years in issue.  Clearly, those gifts            
          (whatever their amounts) would not have been deposited in any of            
          the listed accounts in 1994 or 1995, or otherwise spent by                  
          petitioners in those years, and so no adjustment should be made             
          on account of those 1994 gifts or 1995 gifts.                               
               (d)  On answering brief, petitioners explain their lack of             
          evidence on this issue by stating “that Petitioners were                    
          unsuccessful in persuading any of the relatives to attend the               
          trial as a witness despite numerous efforts.”  However, although            
          petitioners’ witness list includes four close relatives, none of            
          these relatives was to testify about gifts from them (or from any           
          other relatives they were aware of) in 1994 or 1995.                        
               Under these circumstances we conclude that the reason                  
          petitioners did not have evidence of additional gifts that were             
          deposited is that there were not any such additional gifts.  We             
          hold that respondent has established by clear and convincing                
          evidence the correctness of the table 7 and 8 adjustments on                
          account of gifts.                                                           








Page:  Previous  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  49  50  51  52  53  54  55  56  57  58  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011