Michael J. Downing and Sandra M. Downing - Page 56

                                       - 56 -                                         
          from nontaxable sources.28  We consider seriatim the components             
          of the category of cash from nontaxable sources.                            
               (a)  The Newman Property.--Michael sold the Newman property            
          on November 15, 1993.  The net proceeds were $31,307.06.                    
          Respondent, relying on Klimkiewicz’s testimony based on her notes           
          as to what Sandra said at a meeting during the audit, contends              
          that petitioners spent $2,000 of these net proceeds in 1993, had            
          $29,307 left at the beginning of 1994, and spent all this $29,307           
          in 1994.  Petitioners deny the correctness of Klimkiewicz’s notes           
          on this matter and “suggest that at most $1,600 * * * was spent             
          during 1993. * * * For the sake of computing numbers only, the              
          Petitioners will assume the amount of $1,600.”  As a result,                
          petitioners contend that the correct amount for this component is           
          $29,707.  Both sides agree that, by the end of 1994, petitioners            
          spent all that remained of the Newman property proceeds.                    
               Taking into account the conflicting testimony, and the fact            
          that this testimonial conflict is solely as to what Sandra said             
          to Klimkiewicz in 1996 as to Sandra’s 1996 estimate of what                 
          petitioners spent out of this source in 1993, we conclude (and we           


               28  Respondent refers to this category of items as                     
          “nontaxable undeposited cash”.  (Emphasis supplied.)  Yet, for              
          1994 respondent would allow $39,507 to be subtracted, even though           
          respondent would have included only $31,766 of cash expenditures.           
          Thus, respondent appears to have implicitly accepted petitioners’           
          contentions (and Sandra’s testimony) that, at least in 1994,                
          petitioners took money from some cash storage and, at least to              
          the extent of $7,741 ($39,507 minus $31,766), deposited that                
          money into the bank accounts.                                               





Page:  Previous  46  47  48  49  50  51  52  53  54  55  56  57  58  59  60  61  62  63  64  65  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011