Home Health Services Trust, Robert Hogue , Trustee - Page 8




                                        - 8 -                                         
          However, the purported minutes do not state the organization that           
          the minutes pertain to, nor do the purported minutes document               
          Douglas J. Carpa’s alleged notice of resignation, nor Robert                
          Hogue’s alleged appointment as the successor trustee for Home               
          Health, nor Robert Hogue’s or any trustee’s alleged authority to            
          amend the trust instrument.                                                 
               E.  Respondent’s Response                                              
               At the Court’s direction, respondent filed a response to the           
          foregoing objection challenging the authenticity of the purported           
          trust instrument.  Respondent further contends that the objection           
          is identical to a previous objection filed by Robert Hogue in               
          Home Health Servs. Trust v. Commissioner, docket No. 9118-00,               
          which was dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.                               
               F.  Hearing on Respondent’s Motion                                     
               This matter was called for hearing at the Court’s trial                
          session in San Francisco, California.  Counsel for respondent               
          appeared at the hearing and offered argument and evidence in                
          support of respondent’s motion to dismiss.                                  
               Robert Hogue appeared pro se, purportedly on behalf of Home            
          Health.  The only evidence he offered was his naked assertion               
          that he is entitled to appear on behalf of Home Health because he           
          was appointed trustee on July 15, 1997.                                     
               G.  Post-Hearing Memorandum Briefs                                     
               A memorandum brief, which was signed by Robert Hogue, does             






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011