Estate of Nathaniel M. Leichter, Deceased, Steven Leichter, Co-Special Administrator - Page 9




                                        - 9 -                                         
          percent, which was payable monthly.  If the interest was not                
          paid, the amount of interest became part of the principal and was           
          compounded.  The note payable had been secured by a security                
          interest in substantially all of Harlee’s assets and had been               
          recorded by Harlee as a current liability.                                  
               Approximately 4 years later and during the examination of              
          the estate’s tax return, the estate’s attorneys arranged a                  
          meeting with Mr. Sherman and senior management at Harlee to                 
          review and discuss the Sherman Appraisal.  One week later, Mr.              
          Sherman wrote a letter to one of the estate’s representatives               
          claiming that he had made an error on the Sherman Appraisal.  He            
          explained that “During * * * [the] meeting * * * last week, new             
          information was presented to me that was not considered in * * *            
          [the Sherman Appraisal] in 1995.”  Mr. Sherman stated that his              
          error resulted from a misunderstanding as to inventory policy and           
          existing liabilities.                                                       
               A statutory notice of deficiency was issued to the estate on           
          December 6, 1999.                                                           
                                       OPINION                                        
               We consider here the fair market value of a closely held               
          business and whether any discount is appropriate.  The estate               
          reported Harlee’s fair market value at $2,091,750 based on an               
          appraisal that was attached to its estate tax return.  Respondent           
          initially determined that the fair market value was $2,718,358 in           







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011