Gavin Polone - Page 38

                                       - 38 -                                         
               105-599, supra at 239, 1998-3 C.B. at 993; fn. refs.                   
               omitted; emphasis added.]                                              
          The conference committees’s report further states that the Senate           
          amendment provided:                                                         
               [T]he taxpayer must cooperate with reasonable requests                 
               by the Secretary for meetings, interviews, witnesses,                  
               information, and documents (including providing, within                
               a reasonable period of time, access to and inspection                  
               of all witnesses, information, and documents within the                
               control of the taxpayer, as reasonably requested by the                
               Secretary).  Cooperation also includes providing                       
               reasonable assistance to the Secretary in obtaining                    
               access to an inspection of witnesses, information, or                  
               documents not within the control of the taxpayer                       
               (including any witnesses, information, or documents                    
               located in foreign countries).  A necessary element of                 
               cooperating with the Secretary is that the taxpayer                    
               must exhaust his or her administrative remedies                        
               (including any appeal rights provided by the IRS).  The                
               taxpayer is not required to agree to extend the statute                
               of limitations to be considered to have cooperated with                
               the Secretary.  Cooperation also means that the                        
               taxpayer must establish the applicability of any                       
               privilege. * * * [Id. at 240, 1998-3 C.B. at 994; fn.                  
               refs. omitted; emphasis added.]                                        
          Thus, the Senate Amendment changed “full cooperation” to                    
          “cooperation”, “fully cooperate” to “cooperate”, and “fully                 
          cooperate at all times with the Secretary” to “cooperate with               
          reasonable requests by the Secretary for meetings, interviews,              
          witnesses, information, and documents”.  The conference agreement           
          followed the Senate Amendment except for some changes not                   
          relevant to the definition of cooperation.                                  
               Petitioner failed to provide documents within his control              
          requested in the July 26 IDR and November 8 IDR.  Petitioner                
          argues that because the documents contained in the July 26 IDR              





Page:  Previous  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011