Estate of Lucille Abbott Sexton, Deceased, Ann Sexton Peterson, Executor - Page 9




                                        - 9 -                                         
               In selecting Mr. Harkavy, Ms. Sams considered cost,                    
          experience in the specialty, and potential to serve as an expert            
          witness.  Ms. Sams did not perform a conflicts analysis to                  
          determine if a potential for conflict of interest existed.  She             
          was unaware that Mr. Harkavy had a power of attorney on file with           
          respect to his representation of the Sexton estate.  Under the              
          contract, Mr. Harkavy’s charge was to determine the rights of a             
          partnership in connection with certain agreements.  He was not              
          hired by respondent to represent respondent’s interests as                  
          counsel in the McGuire Partners case.  Mr. Harkavy’s involvement            
          in the McGuire Partners case was concurrent with his                        
          representation of the Sexton estate in these consolidated cases.            
          Mr. Harkavy did mention to respondent’s Appeals officer in these            
          consolidated cases that he had been hired as an expert witness by           
          respondent in an income tax case.                                           
               In connection with his consulting position on the McGuire              
          Partners matter, Mr. Harkavy consulted and corresponded with the            
          Appeals officer assigned to that matter.  He also had                       
          communications with the Chief of Appeals and a disclosure officer           
          in respondent’s office.  Mr. Harkavy entered into a nondisclosure           
          agreement with respect to the taxpayer information he was exposed           
          to regarding the McGuire Partners case.                                     
               While Mr. Harkavy was representing the estate, respondent’s            
          attorney, Mr. Klinghoffer, became aware of Mr. Harkavy’s                    






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011