William J. Cutts - Page 16

                                       - 15 -                                         
          allocate the bathroom on the third floor near the den to Mr.                
          Cutts for his personal use.                                                 
               We allocate the bedroom between the den and Justin’s room to           
          Mr. Cutts for personal use.  This bedroom was an integral part of           
          Mr. Cutt’s personal space that he and Justin had to walk through            
          to enter the den.                                                           
               Mr. Cutts lived by himself.  He was not married during the             
          1997 year, and the only child who lived with him--over the summer           
          and on the weekends--was Justin.  Mr. Cutts used his own office             
          and den to handle his personal business and entertainment.  We              
          see no reason why Mr. Cutts would use a third bathroom or any               
          other rooms on the third floor for his personal use.  We allocate           
          the tax office, the storage room, the company bedroom, and the              
          third bathroom on the third floor to ATV for business use.                  
               Unless all ATV employees always ate lunch outside Landmark             
          Hall, it is highly likely ATV employees had access to the kitchen           
          for purposes of storing or making lunches.  ATV also likely used            
          the kitchen to prepare food and beverages for meetings.  Mr.                
          Cutts ate out for lunch and dinner.  His use of the kitchen                 
          occasionally to eat a bowl of cereal was incidental and                     
          insubstantial.  We allocate the kitchen to ATV for business use.            
               Mr. Cutts’s use of his office on the first floor of the main           
          house for personal business and investment work was incidental              
          and insubstantial in relation to Mr. Cutts’s predominant use of             






Page:  Previous  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011