Estate of Antoinette Hartsell, Deceased, Donald C. Renbarger, Personal Representative - Page 19

                                       - 19 -                                         
          death.  Mr. Renbarger made no effort, however, to collect either            
          of the outstanding loans or to collect interest payments from his           
          son.                                                                        
               Mr. Renbarger forgave the loan to himself according, he                
          claims, to decedent’s wishes.  In addition, Randy Renbarger                 
          testified that his interest payments were contingent upon his               
          “ability to pay”, which coincidentally stopped in the same month            
          decedent died.10  Mr. Renbarger thereafter refused to enforce               
          collection of interest payments on Randy Renbarger’s loan,                  
          because he was now the sole beneficiary and, because the loan to            
          his son became his personal property, he just “called it off”.              
          We find Mr. Renbarger’s relinquishment of the estate’s right to             
          accounts receivable and interest payments at a time it owed a               
          significant Federal estate tax not consonant with ordinary                  
          business care and prudence.                                                 
               Respondent also claims the estate made insufficient efforts            
          to obtain a loan.  Mr. Renbarger counters that he made two                  
          informal inquiries, but that in both instances he would have had            
          to personally guarantee the loan, which he was not willing to               
          do.11  There is no evidence in the record that Mr. Renbarger ever           


               10No promissory note for Randy Renbarger’s loan was                    
          submitted into evidence.                                                    
               11Respondent asserts that Mr. Renbarger’s failure to                   
          consider granting a personal guaranty to obtain a loan or                   
          contributing proceeds he received from two annuity contracts to             
                                                             (continued...)           




Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011