Robert James Jaffe - Page 17

                                       - 17 -                                         
               C.  October 1993 Through July 9, 1997                                  
               After the terms of settlement were resolved, it took Ms.               
          Sullivan a number of years to send out closing agreements to the            
          Wilshire investors because she was attempting to get the consent            
          of all the Wilshire investors and settle on the partnership                 
          level.  At some point, Ms. Sullivan changed her mind and decided            
          to send an individual closing agreement to each Wilshire                    
          investor.  Because Mrs. Sullivan’s implementation of this                   
          settlement strategy was not ministerial, no abatement is required           
          for the period when she was attempting to obtain unanimous                  
          consent from the Wilshire partners, including from the                      
          nonconsenting Wilshire investor.  Nothing in the record indicates           
          when Ms. Sullivan made the decision to change the settlement                
          strategy, or when she actually sent out the individual closing              
          agreements.                                                                 
               Recently, this Court held that it was not a ministerial                
          error for respondent to send out closing agreements for a similar           
          Swanton partnership as late as September 9, 1995.  Deverna v.               
          Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2004-80.  If an even greater delay were            
          shown, a further examination of respondent’s actions after that             
          date would be warranted.  However, petitioner has not presented             
          any evidence, from Asher’s TMP or otherwise, that indicates when            
          respondent sent out Asher’s closing agreement.  In fact, the only           
          date in the record relevant to Asher’s closing agreement is the             






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011