Robert Newstat - Page 27

                                       - 27 -                                         
          economic hardship, the taxpayer must submit complete financial              
          data.                                                                       
               Petitioner, however, has never supplied a completed Form               
          433-A or other financial information to respondent, despite                 
          requests from respondent and the efforts and warnings of his own            
          representative.  Mr. Lynch’s June 13, 2002, letter, of which a              
          copy was sent to petitioner, expresses clearly that petitioner              
          would be expected to provide relevant financial disclosure forms            
          at the June 26, 2002, meeting in order to prevent closure of his            
          case and resumption of collection activity.  In light of this               
          admonition, petitioner’s continued recalcitrance after the                  
          conference with regard to supplying the necessary data is not               
          well taken.                                                                 
               Consequently, although the Court is sympathetic to                     
          difficulties petitioner may have encountered in connection with             
          his health and economic situation, it cannot be said that                   
          respondent acted arbitrarily or capriciously in determining to              
          proceed with levy for 1985 when petitioner submitted no                     
          documentation, during or after a proper hearing, of his financial           
          circumstances.  The Court shall sustain respondent’s collection             
          action with respect to 1985.                                                
               B.  1999                                                               
               With respect to 1999, petitioner’s submissions to this Court           
          focus solely on his contention that he did not receive a “due               






Page:  Previous  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011