James M. and Karen K. Barton - Page 11

                                       - 11 -                                         
               In lieu of using the standard mileage rate, we can look to             
          the actual automobile expenses petitioner incurred in 2000.  We             
          have similar concerns about the reliability of evidence in the              
          record to prove petitioner’s “actual” automobile expenses.                  
          First, the master credit card summary showed $2,603 for “Auto               
          Services.”  We note that petitioner testified that this account             
          was used for both business and personal expenses.  We further               
          note that petitioner submitted no evidence to show which of these           
          automobile fuel expenses were for business rather than personal             
          use.  The master credit card summary included a charge for car              
          fuel on February 26, 2000, when petitioner admitted that he and             
          his family were on vacation in San Francisco, California.  In               
          addition, the Court learned that the “Auto Services” amount on              
          the master credit card summary included airplane fuel that                  
          petitioner claimed and was allowed as an airplane expense.                  
               In respondent’s opening brief, respondent conceded that                
          petitioner would be entitled to $1,884 of automobile expenses               
          rather than the $15,741 claimed.  Although we did not find at               
          trial that petitioner satisfied the strict substantiation                   
          requirements regarding the automobile expenses, we shall not                
          disturb respondent’s concession.  Accordingly, petitioner is                
          entitled to an automobile expense deduction of $1,884 for 2000.             









Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011