Faramarz and Mitra Elghanian - Page 14

                                       - 14 -                                         
                                   State               Net                            
               Taxable             Tax   Capital   Sched. E   Operating               
          Year    Wages    Interest Dividends Refund  (Losses)  (Losses)    (Losses)  
          1987               $5,272   $2,957         ($3,000)             ($9,339,066)
          1988   $400,000   262,895  395,255          (3,000)   ($17,708)   (694,227) 
          1989  1,000,000   701,424  218,188          (3,000)   (231,737) (8,622,478) 
          1990              719,826   31,905          (3,000)    (79,383)    (25,850) 
          1991      6,921   133,587   16,136   $958   (3,000)       (447)             
          F.   Events After the 1980s                                                 
               Petitioner married Mitra Rasson in New York, New York, in              
          1990.  Petitioner began living with his family in France at a               
          time not specified in the record before September 11, 2001, and             
          continuing through the date of trial.  His children attend school           
          there.  Petitioner has never become a citizen of the United                 
          States.                                                                     
          G.   Respondent’s Settlement With Petitioner’s Father and Brother           
               Petitioner’s father and Phillip Elghanian each deducted                
          losses of $9,339,066 for 1980 from the expropriation of their               
          Iranian property.  Those losses were carried forward to 1988 and            
          1989 by petitioner’s father and to 1989 by Phillip Elghanian.  In           
          2003, the Commissioner allowed each of them an NOL of $3,868,946.           
                                       OPINION                                        
          A.   Whether the Expropriation Loss Occurred in 1979 or 1986                
               To be a deductible loss under section 165, the transaction             
          must be closed, completed, and fixed by identifiable events in              
          the taxable year.  Boehm v. Commissioner, 326 U.S. 287, 291-292             
          (1945); sec. 1.165-1(b), Income Tax Regs.  Whether a loss                   
          occurred during a particular taxable year is a question of fact.            
          Boehm v. Commissioner, supra at 294; Korn v. Commissioner, 524              





Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011