Edward F. Murphy - Page 40

                                        - 40 -                                        
          before concluding a section 6330 hearing.  Petitioner has failed            
          to show bias.                                                               
               Petitioner claims:  Ms. Boudreau “was not impartial as                 
          [since] she both conducted the hearing and negotiated the offer.”           
          That, however, is precisely the scheme contemplated by section              
          6330.  Section 6330(c)(2)(A)(iii) permits a taxpayer to offer               
          collection alternatives, including offers in compromise, at a               
          section 6330 hearing, and section 6330(c)(3) provides that the              
          determination of the Appeals officer conducting the section 6330            
          hearing shall take into consideration any collection alternative            
          offered by the taxpayer at the hearing.  Petitioner argues:  “It            
          is constitutionally impermissible for the Respondent to assign              
          the same person to negotiate an OIC [offer in compromise] and               
          thereafter rule on the fairness of her negotiations.”  Section              
          6330(b)(3) ensures a measure of impartiality by requiring that,             
          unless the taxpayer waives the requirement, the section 6330                
          hearing be conducted by an Appeals officer who has had no prior             
          involvement with the unpaid tax at issue in the hearing.                    
          Petitioner’s claim is without merit.                                        
               Petitioner claims:  Ms. Boudreau “failed to negotiate during           
          the consideration of the OIC.”  Petitioner argues:  “In failing             
          to negotiate a reasonable offer the Settlement Officer failed to            
          meet her responsibility to hold a fair hearing at which she was             
          to negotiate, be flexible and to make it easier for taxpayers to            






Page:  Previous  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011