Robert Newstat - Page 11

                                        - 11 -                                          
          unspecified business expenses deductions.  Nonetheless, despite               
          having been given every opportunity over a period in excess of 8              
          months between the issuance of our prior opinion and the                      
          supplemental notice of determination, petitioner has failed to                
          produce an iota of supporting documentation substantiating such a             
          claim.  The Court is therefore not in a position to afford                    
          petitioner any relief in this regard.                                         
               2.  Review for Abuse of Discretion                                       
               In evaluating the propriety of a collection determination,               
          the Court reviews for abuse of discretion those issues enumerated             
          in section 6330(c)(2)(A); i.e., spousal defenses, challenges to               
          the appropriateness of the collection action, and offers of                   
          collection alternatives.  Action constitutes an abuse of                      
          discretion under this standard where it is arbitrary, capricious,             
          or without sound basis in fact or law.  Woodral v. Commissioner,              
          112 T.C. 19, 23 (1999).                                                       
               Here, petitioner has at various junctures expressed an                   
          apparent interest in a collection alternative such as an                      
          installment agreement.  However, again despite substantial                    
          additional time to meet the prerequisites for consideration of an             
          alternative collection arrangement, the scenario before the Court             
          remains virtually unchanged from that described within the                    
          context of the 1985 year in Newstat v. Commissioner, supra.  We               
          in that opinion stressed the concept that a taxpayer must supply              






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011