Estate of Lorraine C. Disbrow, Deceased, Martha D. Johnson, Executrix - Page 31

                                        -31-                                          
          checks to generate funds that were used to maintain the                     
          residence.                                                                  
               Petitioner attempts to equate decedent’s payment of rent               
          with FRV by arguing that decedent shared the residence with                 
          others.  As we understand petitioner’s argument, Funny Hats                 
          retained a right under the lease agreements to use (or designate            
          who could use) the residence in derogation of decedent’s wishes             
          and without the payment of rent in that (1) the agreements stated           
          that the “children of the party [decedent] may use the premises”,           
          (2) the partners of Funny Hats were decedent’s children and                 
          children-in-law, and (3) the partners, as effective owners of the           
          residence through their interests in Funny Hats, did not have to            
          pay themselves rent for their (or their designated person’s) use            
          of the residence.  As we further understand petitioner’s                    
          argument, Funny Hats, pursuant to these retained rights, allowed            
          David Disbrow to possess all of the residence, except for                   
          decedent’s bedroom which decedent possessed under the lease                 
          agreements, and decedent, therefore, was required to pay only the           
          portion of the FRV of the residence that corresponded to the                
          portion of the residence that she possessed.  As we understand              
          the conclusion of petitioner’s argument, decedent paid FRV for              
          her “shared usage” of the residence in 2000 in that she paid                
          Funny Hats $4,000 in rent for the first quarter of that year.               







Page:  Previous  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011