Bruce K. and Marina V. Ney - Page 5

                                        - 4 -                                         
          Farm at $181,973.  Each RPC appraisal document indicates an                 
          appraisal date of November 23, 1999, and states:  “The purpose of           
          this appraisal is to estimate the market value of the subject               
          property’s development rights in accordance with the Delaware               
          Agricultural Lands Preservation Foundation.”  (Emphasis omitted.)           
          Neither appraisal document states that it was prepared for income           
          tax purposes.                                                               
               In April 2000, petitioners commissioned a second company,              
          Dover Consulting Services, Inc. (DCS), to appraise Webber Farm.             
          DCS valued the Webber Farm development rights at $238,007 as of             
          April 25, 2000.  The appraisal document states that it was                  
          prepared to “[derive] the market value of the development rights            
          of the property in accordance with the Delaware Agricultural                
          Lands Preservation Foundation provisions, and for no other use.”            
          The appraisal document does not state that it was prepared for              
          income tax purposes.2  For convenience, we refer collectively to            
          the RPC appraisals and the DCS appraisals as the 2000 appraisals.           
               On February 12, 2001, petitioners sold the development                 
          rights to Procko Farm to DALPF for $100,487.3  On the same day,             
          petitioners sold the development rights to Webber Farm to DALPF             
          for $101,572.                                                               



               2 DCS did not appraise Procko Farm in 2000.                            
               3 All amounts are rounded to the nearest dollar.                       





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011