John S. and Christobel D. Rendall - Page 3

                                        - 3 -                                         
                       MEMORANDUM FINDINGS OF FACT AND OPINION                        

               HALPERN, Judge:  By notice of deficiency (the notice),                 
          respondent determined a deficiency of $259,874 in petitioners’              
          1997 Federal income tax.  By the petition, petitioners assign               
          error to respondent’s determination.  Petitioners also assign               
          error to respondent’s denial of their claims for refund for 1997.           
          The allowance of one or more of those claims would result in a              
          refund of $45,400, the amount of tax petitioners paid for 1997.1            
          After concessions,2 the issues for decision are whether                     
          petitioners are entitled to:  (1) Avoid paying tax on the 1997              
          sale of 634,100 shares of Solv-Ex Corp. (Solv-Ex) common stock              
          issued to petitioner John S. Rendall (Mr. Rendall) on the ground            
          that they received no benefit from the proceeds of the sale; (2)            
          alternatively, if they are held to be taxable on that sale,                 


               1  Petitioners’ originally filed 1997 return reports total             
          tax due of $383,632, total tax payments of $45,400, and an amount           
          owed equal to the difference, $338,232 (mistakenly computed to be           
          $338,630 on the return).  Pursuant to sec. 6211(a), Internal                
          Revenue Code of 1986, as amended, the notice determines a                   
          deficiency equal to the excess of the tax properly due, $643,506,           
          over the tax shown on the return, $383,632.  The parties                    
          stipulate that the $338,630 originally reported by petitioners as           
          the amount owed for 1997 has never been paid, except for                    
          $2,001.89 collected as offsets to refunds due petitioners for               
          2001 and 2002.  The record does not indicate whether the balance            
          has been assessed pursuant to sec. 6201(a)(1), Internal Revenue             
          Code of 1986, as amended.                                                   
               2  Petitioners concede that petitioner Christobel Rendall is           
          not entitled to relief from joint and several liability (innocent           
          spouse relief) with respect to any deficiency or underpayment for           
          1997.                                                                       




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011