Larry Bruce - Page 11




                                       - 11 -                                         
          documentation attached.  Further, the information was not current           
          and was grossly insufficient to permit reasonable consideration             
          of an OIC.                                                                  
               There is no abuse of discretion in failing to consider an              
          OIC, when no OIC has been made after a taxpayer has been given a            
          reasonable opportunity to submit one.  Kendricks v. Commissioner,           
          124 T.C. 69, 79 (2005).  Petitioner had adequate opportunity to             
          make an OIC but did not and, therefore, there were no less                  
          intrusive means of collection for the Appeals officer to                    
          consider.  Consequently, the settlement officer considered each             
          item required by section 6330 and reached the determination that            
          the filing of the notice of lien was appropriate.                           
               Furthermore, the information in the Form 433-A weighed                 
          dramatically against the appropriateness of respondent’s                    
          accepting an OIC.  Petitioner listed $5,000 per month in income             
          with $2,725 per month in expenses.  (Petitioner indicated that              
          these expenses were for himself and his girlfriend.  While the              
          allowance of all of these expenses is questionable at the very              
          least, we include all of them for illustration.)  Petitioner                
          valued his assets as: over $4,000 in a checking account, a house            
          worth $80,000, “nice furniture” worth $100,000, a Peterbilt                 
          sleeper cab worth $100,000, a utility trailer worth $65,000, and            
          a pickup truck worth $53,000.  Petitioner owned all of these                
          assets free and clear, with no encumbrances.  The Form 433-A                







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 10, 2007