Thomas Andrew and Diane Koerner Campbell - Page 9




                                        - 8 -                                         
          “public policy” tort, and that tort caused a reduction in pay,              
          all damages received “on account of” that tort by Mrs. Campbell             
          are excludable from income under section 104(a)(2), as it existed           
          pre-1996.                                                                   
               Respondent disputes petitioners’ characterization of Mrs.              
          Campbell’s demotion without benefit of the RIF regulations as a             
          tort and argues that because the only remedy available to an                
          employee for an agency’s violation of the RIF regulations is                
          reinstatement and appropriate backpay, her cause of action                  
          against OTS was not based on “tort or tort type rights” under the           
          definition enunciated by the Supreme Court in Commissioner v.               
          Schleier, supra, and United States v. Burke, supra.  Respondent             
          further argues that, assuming that Mrs. Campbell’s claim against            
          OTS was based on tort or tort type rights, the ordered                      
          restoration of her former pay grade coupled with back wages and             
          lost benefits was not awarded on “account of personal injuries or           
          sickness”, within the meaning of section 104(a)(2), as                      
          interpreted by the Supreme Court.                                           
               We agree with respondent that the backpay and the interest             
          on the backpay awarded by the MSPB were not attributable to any             
          personal injuries or sickness suffered by Mrs. Campbell.  Because           
          we find that the payment in question was not received by Mrs.               
          Campbell “on account of personal injuries or sickness”, as                  
          required by section 104(a)(2) and the second prong of the Supreme           







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 10, 2007