Estate of Burton W. Kanter, Deceased, Joshua S. Kanter, Executor, and Naomi R. Kanter, et al. - Page 215

                                                -286-                                                   
                  Ballard’s explanation for this transaction and petitioners’                           
            treatment of the matter in their reply brief are contradictory.                             
            It is not clear that TMT ever owned shares in Fairfield Planting                            
            Co. that it could transfer to Ballard.  See Petitioners’ Reply                              
            Brief at 625-626.  In any event, Ballard’s testimony suggests the                           
            asset he received, described by him as stock in Fairfield                                   
            Planting Co., was worth considerably more than the $100,000                                 
            charged to him as a loan.  Finally, the terms of Ballard’s                                  
            promissory note associated with this transaction suggest self-                              
            dealing and an effort to create an instrument for a debt that                               
            would never be repaid.  In the absence of any evidence in the                               
            record that TMT ever received any payments (interest, dividends,                            
            or otherwise) attributable to Ballard’s promissory note, we                                 
            conclude that the promissory note was a sham.                                               
                  TMT’s records show that in 1988, TMT purportedly purchased                            
            $15,000 of stock in Ficom International, Inc., a corporation                                
            organized by Ballard’s daughter, Melinda Ballard.  The entry                                
            reflecting the investment includes a handwritten notation “W/O in                           
            1989.”  In 1989, TMT recorded in its trial balance ledger a                                 
            $15,000 long-term capital loss on its investment in Ficom.                                  
            Adjusting journal entry No. 6 explained the writeoff as follows:                            
            “To w/o worthless stock of Ficom as per note on 1988 TB [trial                              
            balance]”.  TMT claimed this loss as a deduction on its 1989 tax                            
            return.                                                                                     






Page:  Previous  276  277  278  279  280  281  282  283  284  285  286  287  288  289  290  291  292  293  294  295  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011