Patrick G. & Valerie V. O'Malley - Page 30




                                        - 30 -                                         
          $254,400 F&M Bank 1999 loan to the alleged venture (alleged                  
          $200,000 contribution), and (c) lend $54,400 of the $254,400 F&M             
          Bank 1999 loan to petitioners (purported $54,400 loan); and                  
          (2) sometime after the December 2, 1999 transaction, (a) Kevin               
          O’Malley was to contribute an additional $100,000 to the alleged             
          venture (additional $100,000 contribution),27 and Mr. O’Malley was           
          to contribute the same amount to the alleged venture.  Petition-             
          ers also contend that on June 3, 2003, they repaid Kevin O’Malley            
          the purported $54,400 loan.                                                  
               In support of petitioners’ contentions with respect to the              
          alleged venture, including the purported $54,400 loan, petition-             
          ers rely on the testimony of Mr. O’Malley and certain checks that            
          petitioners issued to Kevin O’Malley about which Mr. O’Malley                
          testified.  We found that testimony of Mr. O’Malley to be gen-               
          eral, vague, conclusory, and/or incomplete, and we shall not rely            
          on that testimony to establish petitioners’ contentions as to                
          that alleged venture.  To illustrate, Mr. O’Malley’s testimony               
          was general, vague, conclusory, and incomplete regarding Kevin               
          O’Malley’s alleged $200,000 contribution to the alleged venture.             
          The December 2, 1999 settlement statement showed $250,902 of the             
          proceeds of the $254,400 F&M Bank 1999 loan as “CASH TO SELLER               

               27According to petitioners, petitioners were to repay the               
          purported $54,400 loan to Kevin O’Malley at the time Kevin                   
          O’Malley was to make his additional $100,000 contribution to the             
          alleged venture, and Kevin O’Malley was to use such funds, as                
          well as additional funds, to make that contribution.                         






Page:  Previous  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  Next 

Last modified: November 10, 2007