David L. Samuel - Page 18




                                       - 18 -                                         
          The $15,600 which Dr. Samuel paid for his 2003 estimated tax                
          payment should have been excluded from the dissipated assets                
          category, and if Appeals was in doubt about the includability of            
          the $5,000 incurred in association with Dr. Samuel’s civil law              
          suit and the $5,464 paid for child support, these amounts should            
          have been excluded also.  It was an abuse of discretion not to do           
          so.                                                                         
               It is represented in his brief that petitioner has been                
          current on all of the filings and payments of his taxes, starting           
          with 2003.  It appears from the Appeals Case Determination that             
          petitioner has in fact minimal assets from which cash could be              
          realized, but that he has a medical practice that produces a                
          fairly substantial amount of income.  Clearly, then, any IRS                
          recovery from petitioner would have to come principally, if not             
          entirely, from his medical practice income.                                 
               In connection with its consideration of petitioner’s offer-            
          in-compromise, Appeals prepared the following table to illustrate           
          petitioner’s future income potential.  The Case Determination               
          states that the table is intended to show that petitioner’s                 
          future income potential is more than his $30,000 offer.                     
               Total Income               Necessary Living Expenses                   
               Source         Gross                    Claimed   Allowed              
               Wages/salaries  $7,963   Natl.Std       $976      $953                 
               T/P                      expenses                                      
               Wages/salaries           Housing &      1,024      1,034               
               spouse                   utilities                                     
               Interest                 Transportation      0          0              
               Net business             Health care    50        100                  






Page:  Previous  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  Next 

Last modified: November 10, 2007