Rhett Rance Smith and Alice Avila Smith, et al. - Page 13




                                        - 13 -                                        
          one-page November 19, 2001, letter from Mr. Koehl to Rance                  
          referring to an $8,500-per-share valuation for Beneco as of March           
          31, 2000.  Also attached to Zane and Shannon’s 2001 return was an           
          acknowledgment from CCF of its receipt of the limited partnership           
          interest, advising that “No goods or services were provided for             
          this donation.”  Finally, there was attached an assignment of an            
          FLP interest in Mustard Seed, along with a signed consent from CCF          
          by its president.                                                           
               From 1995 through 2001, Rhett and Alice assigned interests in          
          Zerubbabel to CCF and claimed corresponding noncash charitable              
          contribution deductions on their personal income tax returns, as            
          follows:                                                                    
                                  Percent Assigned         Claimed                   
                    Date            Per Tax Return        Contribution                
                  12/20/95             11.587%             $185,000                   
                  12/29/97               3.92              Unknown                    
                  12/29/00             2.2851              100,000                    
                  12/31/01              13.674             290,000                    
               Although Rhett and Alice’s Form 8283 for 2000 contained the            
          statement that an interest of 2.2851 percent had been contributed           
          to CCF, the actual percentage contributed was 4.57 percent.                 
          Pursuant to Rhett and Alice’s request, CCF directed their 1995-             
          2001 assigned interests in their FLP (Zerubbabel) to Zacchaeus.             
          Rhett and Alice did not donate Beneco stock to CCF during the               
          years 1998 through 2001.                                                    








Page:  Previous  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next 

Last modified: March 27, 2008