HUANG et al. V. PRASIT et al. - Page 12




                    25. Huang disagrees with Merck's admission but                    
          argues that Merck should be held to its prior admission and                 
          should not be able to take a position in this interference                  
          that is contrary to the position it took in the '845 and '873               
          interferences                                                               
          (Paper 47 at 4).                                                            
                    26. Both Dr. Chang and Dr. Riendeau testified that                
          their views were reached after "carefully stud(ying)"                       
          applications 08/004,822 and 08/425,029 (applications involved               
          in the '845 and '873 interferences).                                        
                    27. At a point in his testimony prior to his                      
          testimony set out at FF  22, Dr. Chang testified (Exh. 2002 at1                                                    
          ¶7):                                                                        
               I have carefully studied the Bertenshaw Applications                   
               USSN 08/004,822 (DE 62), USSN 08/425,029 (DE 61,                       
               pages 0146-0233) and the Declaration on behalf of                      
               Ducharme of Dr. Denis Riendeau (DE 16) and based on                    
               the study I have found the following:                                  

                    28. At a point in his testimony prior to his                      
          testimony set out at FF 22, Dr. Riendeau testified (Exh. 2003               
          at ¶9):                                                                     




               1    Finding of Fact.                                                  
                                         12                                           





Page:  Previous  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007