Appeal No. 95-4547 Application No. 08/097,697 shock and means for detecting defects in the reproduced data signal using envelope detection and that Anderson teaches the generation of supplemental position error signal values from a plurality of locations around a rotation of a disk. Therefore, concludes the examiner, it would have been obvious to have modified the servo control apparatus of Ohtake...such that the memory would hold servo signals from an entire rotation of the disk, as taught by Anderson...in order to achieve a high degree of accuracy in head positioning around an entire rotation of a disk during operation [answer, page 5]. The examiner further concludes that since Baba teaches a first and second detection means for detecting surface defects and external shock, respectively, that it would have been obvious to have incorporated the data signal defect detection means and the external shock detection means as taught by Baba...into the apparatus taught by the combination of Ohtake...and Anderson...in order to provide a means for maintaining accurate tracking control when detection errors occur during data reproduction, due to surface defects of the disc, and when external shocks to the optical head are encountered, by providing additional control signals to the memory hold circuit of Ohtake...[answer, page 6]. 4Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007