Ex parte HAAR et al. - Page 10




          Appeal No. 95-4590                                                          
          Application 08/056,188                                                      



          to its stay . . .    2. an eyelet, as of metal or plastic,                  
          protecting an opening in cloth, leather, etc."  In appellants'              
          specification (page 5)    it is merely indicated that "the                  
          carrying bag has a number of grommets 43 secured to the body                
          portion 12"; however, there is  no other description of these               
          elements.  In Figure 1 of the drawings of the application, the              
          "grommets" are shown by reference character (43), which                     
          essentially point to the rings that                                         


          are secured in some fashion to the sidewall of the body of the              
          bag.  Since the "grommet" structure shown in Figure 1 of                    
          appellants' drawings is clearly not an eyelet protecting an                 
          opening in the fabric sidewall of the bag, we therefore                     
          conclude that the "grommet" disclosed and shown by appellants               
          is merely a ring structure secured to the bag which provides a              
          point of attachment for other accessories, such as the handle               
          (45) seen in Figure 1. Appellants' specification, at page 5,                
          lines 16-27, appears to support such an understanding of                    
          appellants' "grommets."  Given this understanding of the                    
          "grommets" set forth in appellants' claim 21 on appeal, we                  

                                          10                                          





Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007