Ex parte ALBERTSON - Page 5




          Appeal No. 96-0667                                                          
          Application 08/061,249                                                      

          fee for advertising.  Rather, the claims require that the                   
          statement rendered to the businesses include thereon "the cost of           
          each telephone call to each selected business location, cost of             
          1+800-XXX service, and cost of advertising associated with each             
          selected pay telephone" [emphasis ours]-claim 1; or "the cost of            
          each telephone call to the assigned telephone number from each              
          pay telephone for the cost of each telephone call and the cost of           
          advertising associated with each pay telephone" [emphasis ours]-            
          claim 7.                                                                    
                    As recognized by appellant, at page 9 of the brief,               
          while businesses certainly have been charged for advertising and            
          for toll-free telephone service, the bill therefor included a               
          total charge for the service without regard to the particular               
          telephone from which the calls were made.  As explained by                  
          appellant, "[t]hese bills are not separated for selected pay                
          telephone locations with supporting statements for calls from the           
          selected pay telephone along with costs of advertising located              
          adjacent the selected pay telephone."  As required by the instant           
          claims, the statement rendered according to the claimed method              
          includes, inter alia, the "cost of advertising associated with              
          each selected pay telephone."  This is not taught or suggested by           
          the prior art of record.                                                    


                                         -5-                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007