Ex parte GAO et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 96-1353                                                          
          Application 07/696,973                                                      


          the manner proposed by the examiner, and that MacKay is                     
          nonanalogous art and therefore is improperly considered.                    
               Jasper discloses a traveling wave tube in which a super-               
          conducting circuit is formed upon a substrate.  Superconductor              
          material is applied in a pattern to the substrate by the                    
          technique of plasma spraying and becomes fused to the substrate.            
          The examiner has acknowledged that the material deposited by the            
          plasma spraying is an oxide, which would indicate that a                    
          subsequent oxidation process is not necessary, and none is taught           
          in this reference.                                                          
               Ashok is directed to the manufacture of superconducting                
          structures and teaches depositing a superconductor material upon            
          a moving belt by means of an atomizer nozzle in which pressurized           
          gas is used as a vehicle for moving a molten stream of metal.               
          The resulting product is a continuous strip or a series of broken           
          strips (Figures 2 and 3; column 4, lines 13 through 17).  The               
          required oxidation of the superconductor material can be                    
          accomplished either by atomizing it in an oxidizing atmosphere or           
          oxidizing it after deposition on the moving belt (Abstract).                
               MacKay discloses an apparatus for dispensing liquid metals             
          in small controlled volumes upon such items as an electronic                
          substrate in drops (Figure 1) or in strips (Figure 4) for use in            

                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007