Ex parte LYLES et al. - Page 8




          Appeal No. 96-1692                                                          
          Application 08/156,811                                                      



          through 5  and 20 on appeal, or of a "method of assembling a land           
          vehicle" as set forth in appellants' claim 21 on appeal.  It                
          would appear to be the examiner's position that the applied                 
          references somehow each "inherently" teach or suggest the claimed           
          methods of assembly based simply on the disclosure of a given               
          type of golf car including, in one case, a chassis and an                   
          electric motor drive system (Gardner) and in another case, a                
          chassis and an internal combustion engine drive system (Westmont            
          and Lanius).  In this                                                       





          regard, the examiner has stated on page 7 of the answer                     
          that                                                                        
                    the prior art cited and applied to                                
                    appellant's [sic] claims has been                                 
                    selected from a group of drive system                             
                    types or selected from a group of body                            
                    part types or selected from a group of                            
                    body part styles.  Although the                                   
                    reference may show one drive system, or                           
                    one body part or one body part style it                           
                    meets the claimed recitation of                                   
                    "selecting a type...from a group of                               
                    types...".                                                        



                                          8                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007