Ex parte ODAGAWA - Page 5




          Appeal No. 96-2418                                                          
          Application 08/137,267                                                      


          error distance or least mean square criteria to reduce                      
          computation complexity to obtain Appellant’s invention as recited           
          in Appellant’s claims 1 and 9.                                              
               Appellant argues on pages 12 and 13 of the brief that the              
          Honey system determines which segments intersect the CEP and                
          determines whether there exists a segment intersecting                      
          the CEP that corresponds to the initial position DRP .                      
                                                              0                       


          Appellant’s invention as recited in the independent claims sets             
          second position candidacies forward and backward of the present             
          position candidacy on the road in which the vehicle is currently            
          travelling.  Appellant argues that this is not taught or                    
          suggested by Honey.  Similarly, Appellant argues that Honey does            
          not teach or suggest any controlling means for setting the first            
          present and second present position candidacies on positions                
          corresponding to the road forward and backward of the first                 
          present position candidacy as recited in Appellant’s claim 9.               
               Upon a closer inspection, we find that Honey teaches in                
          column 3, line 44, through column 4, line 25, a method for                  
          providing information to improve the accuracy of tracking a                 
          vehicle comprising the step of deriving any of a plurality of               
          parameters to determine if a more probable current position                 

                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007