Ex parte ODAGAWA - Page 6




          Appeal No. 96-2418                                                          
          Application 08/137,267                                                      


          exists.  In column 18, lines 15-51, Honey discloses that Figure 8           
          is a flow chart illustrating the overall vehicle navigational               
          algorithm.  In block 8C, a multi-parameter evaluation is                    
          performed by computer 12 to determine if a segment S in the                 


          navigation neighborhood contains a point which is more likely               
          than the current dead reckoned position DRP .  In column 20,                
                                                     c                                
          lines 23-60, Honey discloses that Figure 14 shows the flow chart            
          of the subroutine for determining the most probable line segment            
          S.  First, the X,Y coordinate data of a line segment S are                  
          fetched by computer 12 from the navigation neighborhood of the              
          map.  Then, the computer 12 determines if this line segment S is            
          parallel to the heading H of the vehicle within a threshold.  If            
          the segment S is parallel, then the computer 12 determines if               
          this line segment S intersects the contour of equal probability,            
          CEP.  However, Honey does not teach setting second position                 
          candidacies forward and backward of the present position                    
          candidacy on the road in which the vehicle is currently                     
          travelling.                                                                 
               In addition, Appellant argues on page 2 of the reply brief             
          that the mere assertion by the Examiner that use of contours of             
          equal probability would have provided the motivation for those              

                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007